Controversy Over Heaven
By: Dr. Gary Scott Smith
The Red Hook section of Brooklyn recently renamed a street â€œSeven in Heaven Wayâ€ to honor seven firefighters who died trying to rescue victims of the September 11, 2001 attacks at the World Trade Center. The street was given this new name because the men who diedâ€”Joseph Gullickson, Brian Cannizzaro, Salvatore Calabro, Thomas Kennedy, Patrick Byrne, Joseph Maffeo, and Terence McShaneâ€”have long been known as â€œSeven in Heaven.â€ This simple act has provoked substantial debate over the public use of religious language and the afterlife.
The New York City Atheists organization protested that this renaming violated the separation of church and state. The groupâ€™s president complained that public signs with religious messages are â€œreally insulting to usâ€ because they are convinced that neither heaven nor hell exists. The spokesperson of American Atheists demanded the city remove the sign because â€œHeaven is a specifically Christian placeâ€ and therefore the claim that these â€œheroes are in heavenâ€ is â€œpreachyâ€ and â€œnot appropriate.â€ â€œItâ€™s improper for the city to endorse the view that heaven exists,â€ he declared, because â€œit links Christianity and heroism.â€
Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz countered that â€œthese seven brave souls who â€¦ gave up the most precious gift that could be given â€¦ are in heaven for serving us so admirably.â€ These men who died trying to save others from burning rubble, another Brooklyn official stated, â€œare heroes and should be rewarded in a place like heaven.â€
Southern Baptist ethicist Richard Land pointed out that American cities such as Los Angeles, Corpus Christi, and St. Joseph have religious names. â€œIn a country where 85 percent of the people say they are Christian,â€ he added, it makes sense for cities and streets to employ religious terms.
Jay Sekulow of the American Center for Law and Justice asserted that â€œthe claim that somehow â€˜Seven in Heaven Wayâ€™ violates the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment is absurd. Acknowledging religion is not an endorsement of religion, and to suggest that this street name somehow crosses the constitutional line of establishing a religion is nonsense.â€
One internet site received nearly 400 responses to the incident, many of which pointed out that heaven is not unique to Christians. Jews, Muslims, Shintoists, and others believe in heaven. One atheist proclaimed, â€œI think that naming the street â€˜Seven in Heavenâ€™ is a superb way of honouring [sic] those heroic firefighters. These moronic attacks on Christianity embarrass me.â€ Others complained â€œyou can sneeze and offend an atheistâ€ or warned â€œone day they will meet GODâ€¦. Then they will know the truth.â€ Few, though, questioned whether heroic action guaranteed admission to heaven.
Debates over heaven and the nature of the afterlife are as old as humanity itself. The ancient Babylonians, Egyptians, Greeks, and Romans all depicted a future existence where heroes rested, pharaohs resided, or the righteous picnicked in Elysian Fields. Australian aborigines as well as early Polynesians, Peruvians, Mexicans, and Native Americans all developed ideas about the afterlife.
Many other Americans have been deeply interested in life after death. From the works of Puritan Increase Mather, to the sermons of theologian Jonathan Edwards, the writings of 19th-century revivalists like Dwight Moody, the books and sermons of evangelist Billy Graham, and the novels of Mitch Albom and Alice Sebold, thousands have offered visions of heaven or how to get there. Evangelicals have led the way, but mainline Protestants, Catholics, Jews, Mormons, spiritualists, New Agers, Muslims, and numerous others have also described heaven and its entrance requirements.
Thousands of books, articles, and essays on heaven have been published, countless sermons have been preached about the subject, and hymns about heaven have been popular. Jokes, works of art, and kitsch about heaven have proliferated in recent decades. Artists, musicians, social scientists, philosophers, theologians, pastors, evangelists, and novelists have all offered perspectives.
Recently, interest in heaven has become even greater. Polls consistently find that high percentages of Americans believe in heaven and expect to spend eternity there. Various polls show that 80-90 percent of Americans believe in heaven. A Gallup Poll reported that 77 percent of Americans rated their chances of getting to heaven as â€œgoodâ€ or â€œexcellent.â€ Several near-death experience accounts of heavenâ€”Don Piperâ€™s â€œ90 Minutes in Heaven,â€ â€œHeaven Is for Real: A Little Boyâ€™s Astounding Story of His Trip to Heaven and Back,â€ and â€œThe Boy Who Came Back from Heavenâ€â€”are all best sellers. Given this and the deep impact of 9/11 on Americans, the lively debate over the naming of this street in Brooklyn is not surprising. Belief in heaven has provided millions of Americans with hope as they face earthly struggles and death and has frequently helped inspire them to improve conditions on earth.
Dr. Gary Scott Smith chairs the history department at Grove City College and is a fellow for faith and the presidency with The Center for Vision & Values. He is the author of â€œFaith and the Presidency From George Washington to George W. Bushâ€ (Oxford University Press, 2009) and the newly released â€œHeaven in the American Imaginationâ€ (Oxford University Press, 2011).
— Dr. Gary Scott Smith chairs the history department at Grove City College and is a fellow for faith and the presidency with The Center for Vision & Values. His most recent book is “Heaven in the American Imagination” (Oxford University Press, 2011).